Tuesday, July 29, 2008

Some classical mechanics

While it'll take a while to get all my Paris pictures sorted out, I've fallen back to some light internet reading. Forget your quarks, photons, neutrinos and whatever else in physics that are way beyond my comprehension. Have you ever stopped to think about how a bicycle works? Have you actually cared enough to find out afterwards? Well, today's the day I answer yes. My first thought was that gyroscopic forces from the spinning wheels keep the bicycle stable and upright. As it turns out, people have gone to great lengths to disprove that theory. Behold the zero-gyro bike, where two counter-rotating wheels cancel the gyroscopic effect of the main wheels. As it turns out, while it is very possible to ride a zero-gyro bike, it is impossible to ride a bike with its steering column locked in the forward position, unless the wheels are huge and gyroscopic forces actually dominate. Thus, it's actually the act of the rider that keeps a bike upright. As the figure shows, the bike is balanced as long as the moments created by gravity and centrifugal force balance each other. The system itself is not stable without a feedback controller, the rider. The rider has control over v, r and q by the acts of peddling, steering and leaning, which offers enough redundancy to ensure the moments are balanced even with external disturbances. Evidently, the bike cannot be balanced when v is zero because a centrifugal force is not possible, not because there is no gyroscopic effect from rotating wheels. On the other hand, here's a monstrocity I've only discovered today: the gyro monorail. While it might intuitively work like a bicycle, it's actually quite different. There is no control over r (due to the fixed tracks), and it would be difficult to control q directly. Thus this thing stays up purely by a giant spinning gyroscope inside the cabin. A control system keeps control over the precession of the gyroscope, which maintains the balance of the vehicle. At first glance it seems strange to see this thing stand, but after reading the article, I'm actually convinced that this system has a lot of advantages over traditional two rail systems. As the co-inventor Piotr Schilovski pointed out, it was generally ignorance in the engineering community that prevented this idea from being implemented.

3 comments:

  1. Very interesting!

    Of course, now when I bike I'll be thinking about physics, so I'll probably run into a tree or something...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Actually I've long been wondering about this while riding bikes, often (unsafely) using my right hand to picture the angular momentum and torque vectors.

    It's one of those things that you forget about as soon as you have something better to do. Other things belonging to that category: how a swing can be pumped (counterintuitive that angular momentum is not conserved?), and how the forces balance inside a banking airplane (the water in the cup stays level).

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wrong ... the forces are just too small.
    LOL ,Wikipedia is a poor source of information or you read it incorrectly . That is a picture of the Brennan Gyro Monorail "1910"which just happens to use two counter rotating gyroscopes with horizontal axis's just like bicycle wheels and worked perfectly according to many sources , there are pictures of the 6 ft prototype driving across a cable .Your test proved nothing because they didn't cancel each other out they actually made it a little more stable . The key is the wheels add so little stability a slow speeds it doesn't matter .As always empirical data trumps theory every time .From personal experince there is more of an effect after you hit 30 mph . Frankly a bicycle wheel is very light be a good gyroscope though I might experiment for a few laughs .Your teacher didn't see the problem with this ? Check this link :http://www.catskillarchive.com/rrextra/odgyro.Html and http://www.aqpl43.dsl.pipex.com/MUSEUM/LOCOLOCO/brennan/brennan.htm
    Lets see if you even check back on this after 2 yrs.
    And good luck in school I hope you do well .

    ReplyDelete